- Created on Friday, 05 April 2013 19:24
NEW BRUNSWICK, N.J.
Tim Pernetti didn’t have a chance to speak for himself or defend his actions — or lack thereof — at Friday’s press conference announcing his resignation as athletic director at Rutgers University.
But if the intimations made in the embattled former AD’s letter of resignation are to be believed, Pernetti is simply being made the unwitting scapegoat for a much larger institutional failure surrounding the handling of former basketball coach Mike Rice’s treatment of players.
And, whether Pernetti’s claims are true or not, presenting them as factual is probably the best-case scenario for everyone involved in this hotly debated unraveling of the Scarlet Knights’ athletic program, which has dominated the news cycle in a way that Rutgers’ hoops team has never dreamed of doing with its play on the court.
In Pernetti’s letter, which Rutgers president Robert Barchi read in full during a contentious hourlong Q-and-A session that felt more like a cross-examination on a TV drama, the former Rutgers tight end claimed that his first instinct after seeing video of Rice verbally and physically abusing players on the practice court was to “fire him immediately,” but that others at the university intervened before such action could be taken.
"Rutgers decided to follow a process involving university lawyers, human resources professionals, and outside counsel," Pernetti wrote. "Following review of the independent investigative report, the consensus was that university policy would not justify dismissal. I have admitted my role in, and regret for, that decision, and wish that I had the opportunity to go back and override it for the sake of everyone involved."
Pernetti’s defense of his own inaction may not be accurate — and it’s very possible that it isn’t — but that’s of little importance, of course. Because Barchi, himself, did nothing to dispute the assertion, seeming content to paint Pernetti as a chump and himself as remorseful that he didn’t do more to intervene. Essentially, Barchi allowed Pernetti to be a martyr so long as he would take the blame.
“Tim Pernetti is a sincere and honest man,” Barchi said. “He is a skilled athletic director with many strengths. … I believe he has always had the good of Rutgers and its student athletes in mind in every decision he has made, including his decision today. This mutual decision is in the best interest of Rutgers, and we will learn from this situation going forward.”
It also matters little how much Barchi really knew about Rice’s despicable behavior and when he was made aware of what was going on with his school’s athletic program.
Because, in making Pernetti the fall guy, Barchi absolved himself of any wrongdoing in the case — other than to say that he regretted lacking the power of hindsight when he elected not to watch the tape in November, when Eric Murdock, who was fired from the Rutgers basketball staff last summer, brought it to the university’s attention.
“This was a failure of process,” Barchi said. “I regret that I did not ask to see the video when Tim first told me of its existence, because I am certain this situation would have had a different outcome had I done so.”
And Barchi willingly did all this — pinning the oversight in the Rice case on Pernetti — with the backing of Ralph Izzo, the chair of the university board of governors, by his side, assuring Barchi that his job, which he has only held since September, is not in jeopardy. So Barchi wins in that he can move forward, with a cushy job, in the search for a new AD and basketball coach.
It’s not a perfect solution to the problem by any stretch, and it does little to explain how Rice could have possibly only received a three-game suspension and $50,000 fine in the first place for what was so obviously a fireable offense. It also doesn’t eliminate the potential effects of the pending lawsuit, which was filed by Murdock in state court Friday.
On the court, it doesn’t do a largely irrelevant Rutgers program any favors in recruiting going forward, either, and the images of Rice hitting and kicking players, throwing basketballs at them, and slinging homophobic slurs in their direction, won’t soon be forgotten.
But finally settling on who, exactly, was to blame — Rice, and then Pernetti, in short order — helps bring something like closure to the scandal, which has effectively overshadowed this weekend’s Final Four.
Friday’s press conference wasn’t a surprise, and it didn’t answer most of the questions people still have about the events of the past week. But it was a carefully crafted ploy that allowed everyone to walk away looking as good as possible in a situation where no one really looks all that great.
By firing the worst guy, letting the bad guy resign and walk away with his image somewhat intact and allowing the guy at the head of it all off scot-free, it gives the university an opportunity to move on and recover from the black eye its athletic program has sustained over the last week. And given the circumstances, that’s probably the best Pernetti, Barchi and the school could have hoped for.
- Jason Cote is convicted of murder and to be sentenced Friday
- Governor says he'll be the education commissioner
- Maine filmmakers release romantic comedy
- Sen. King to host opiate discussion in Bangor on Friday
- New business to be geared towards outdoor activities
- Two Maine companies are giving back
- Seven people arrested for dealing heroin and cocaine
- Candidates turn their focus to the next primary in South Carolina
- Attack in Hollis ends in one arrest
- The presidential race has made its way to Maine
- Sanders campaign breaks fundraising efforts as donations average $34
- Body found under frozen lake
- Director of Houlton Shelter Resigns, Police Investigating
- Man arrested for sexual assault, his victim is 11 year old girl
- Bangor Historical Society invites you to make Valentines
- Maine Discovery Museum host February vacation camp
- Maine Audubon is putting on exciting camps for students during February vacation
- Connecticut State Trooper has been shot and killed by a Maine man
- Maine corporation charged with growing marijuana is ordered to pay fine
- Cats abandoned at shelter over night
- Ex-pharma CEO Shkreli offers Kanye West $10M for upcoming album
- Virginia high school nixes 'white guilt' video after criticism
- How impoverished but nuclear-armed North Korea earns money
- US, Russia and UN say Syria fighting 'cessation' to take effect next week
- Ohio police kill man who allegedly attacked people with machete
- At least 4 injured in machete attack at Ohio restaurant
- Does Bernie Sanders really want to win? Three Democratic debate takeaways
- Fear pervasive after Mexican prison riot that killed 49
- Dem Debate: Clinton, Sanders clash on ObamaCare; join in slamming police
- Dem Debate: Clinton, Sanders clash over Wall Street ties
- Differences Undefined? Clinton, Sanders unite in police criticism amid testy debate
- The Latest: Teen who killed family ordered to treatment
- Diplomats in Munich agree to Syria cease-fire in a week
- Fargo police say officer shot during standoff dies
- University of Rochester scientists create 'super polymer' that can lift 1,000 times its mass
- Do or Die: Nevada lawmaker describes convincing last Oregon holdout to surrender
- Locals fume as EPA reveals Gold King mine spill much worse than initially stated
- Top terror groups focused on targeting planes, DHS secretary says
- State Dept. IG subpoenaed Clinton Foundation in 2015
- Final Oregon refuge occupier turns himself in
- World's longest-surviving heart transplant patient dies
- 'House of Cards': It's Frank vs. Claire in the Season 4 trailer
- Hundreds of people, including strangers, attend funeral for homeless Army vet
- Meryl Streep responds to questions about diversity: 'We’re all Africans really'
- 'The Originals': Leah Pipes On The 'Insane' Danger Cami Is In, Getting Lectured By Klaus & Elijah
- Lamar Odom Makes Public Return At Kanye West's Fashion Show
- Teresa Giudice Talks Prison Life, Reuniting With Family & Supporting Donald Trump
- Peyton Manning & Jimmy Fallon Have Fun With Eli Manning's Super Bowl Face
- [EXCLUSIVE] Bethenny Frankel Confirms She is Returning to 'RHONY'
- 'Legends Of Tomorrow': Marc Guggenheim On Ray & Snart’s Latest Mission, Training Kendra & The Omega Protocol
- Adam Levine Reacts To Taraji P. Henson’s Coldplay/Maroon 5 Mix-Up
- 'The 100 Q&A: Brenda Strong On Playing Ice Nation Queen Nia
- 'Outlander' Season 2 Premiere Date Announced
- 'Outlander' Season 2 Premiere Date Announced, New Trailer Drops
- Stars Step Out For Saint Laurent Hollywood Show
- 'Gilmore Girls' Revival Welcomes More Familiar Faces
- Gwen Stefani Teaming With Target For Live Grammy Video
- Adele Announces Surprise Pre-Grammy Concert
- 'Arrow': Katrina Law Previews 'Epic' Fight, 'Beautiful' Nyssa/Laurel Scene
- Eagles Band Members To Honor Glenn Frey At Grammys
- Johnny Depp Stars As Donald Trump In Funny Or Die Spoof
- Medical Examiner Rules Michael Cavallari's Death Accidental
- 'Frozen' Musical To Make Broadway Debut In 2018
- DMX Has Recovered After Being Resuscitated By Police, Attorney Says
- Kelly Clarkson Releasing Children's Book Named For Daughter River Rose
- Megan Fox Is New 'New Girl,' Filling In For Zooey Deschanel
- Bryan Fuller Named Co-Creator, Showrunner Of CBS' 'Star Trek'
- Ken Watanabe Battling Stomach Cancer, Delays Broadway Return
- Tom Brady boasts that he is not one of the best QBs ever
- Peyton Manning's mom explains why it's time for her son to retire
- Report: Off-duty cops hospitalized after alleged altercation involving LeSean McCoy
- Advanced stats will probably love Michigan in 2016
- Audi tearjerker, 'Puppymonkeybaby' among Super Bowl winners
- Offbeat humor and upbeat messages dominate Super Bowl ads
- Breaking news: NASCAR to announce new 'charter' system for teams
- 2nd-seeded Cilic and Dodig advance to 2nd round in Rotterdam
- Jordan Spieth honors Peyton Manning with classic forehead joke after Super Bowl win
- Mets give cap-tip to fellow runner-up Panthers after Super Bowl loss
- Cam Newton's authenticity is highly questionable
- 2016 New York Mets Preview & Fantasy Baseball Draft Prep
- All-Star Bobblehead Series among Marlins promotions in 2016
- Broncos offseason to-do list, starting with moving on from Manning
- Cam Newton's image took the biggest hit of all during the Super Bowl
- Dodgers' Pederson had a great view of Super Bowl 50 Halftime Show
- Paul George says he'll try to score 82 points in final game vs. Kobe
- From behind the lens at Super Bowl 50, Durant captures the other side
- DeMarcus Ware's son stole Deion Sanders' microphone after the Super Bowl
- Comfort wins: Stroman, Blue Jays watch Super Bowl 50 in onesies
- Parker to play with France despite wife's pregnancy
- Ronaldo open to leaving Real Madrid when contract expires
- Tyronn Lue on recent criticism: 'Look, they ridiculed Jesus Christ'
- Bryce Harper shared a laugh with Stephen Curry at Super Bowl 50