BANGOR - Nicholas Sexton spent his testimony painting a picture where Randall Daluz called the shots and took control of the situation.
"I think he gave an accurate sequence of events that made sense from the evidence and I don't think this ended up as it started out as," says Sexton's attorney Jeffrey Toothaker.
He claims he was driving the car when Daluz and Daniel Borders had an altercation. That's when he says Daluz started to hit Borders in the head with a gun, accidentally shooting and killing him.
He went on to say Lucas Toscano was shot when he spoke up to Daluz, and Nicolle Lugdon was shot some time later after Daluz forced her to eat pills.
But there were some inconsistencies. the prosecution and Daluz's lawyer questioning why Sexton would place more than a dozen calls to Daluz the following day - a man he said he was scared of.
Sexton also claimed he filled the vehicle with diesel - something that isn't scientifically possible.
"His testimony was inconsistant with itself, was insconsitant with the way the forensics were establised and were inconsistant with what one would expect from the perspection of reality," explains Jeffrey Silverstein, Daluz's lawyer.
It's unclear if Daluz will take the stand. If he doesn't, lawyers are optimistic this case will be put in the jury's hands sometime on Tuesday.
Jaclyn Cangro joined WVII ABC 7 and WFVX Fox 22 in September of 2013. She was raised in suburban New York and graduated cum laude from Emerson College with a Bachelor’s degree in Broadcast Journalism in 2013.
While at Emerson, she won the 2012 New England Emmy Award for Best College Newscast as co-executive producer. She was also nationally ranked by the Sportscasters Talent Agency of America (STAA) as one of the Top 20 Sports Broadcasters in the country, being one of two females on the list.
When not on the air, she enjoys watching and rooting for the New York Mets and New England Patriots.
She’s excited to explore all Maine has to offer! If you have any story ideas, contact her at JCangro@wvii.com or tweet her @jaclyncangro.